BATTERS: Risky Business

As much as owners want to believe otherwise, there are no sure things in baseball. It has been discussed in this space previously, but one need only look at the return on first round picks in the last few years to know that even the most talented players are a volatile commodity. While owners can't predict the future, they can attempt to avoid expensive players whose skills and/or history suggest increased risk for a lag in production.

This week's article covers some of the players that are risky propositions to return positive value given their current draft positions. Whether due to injury risk, curious BPI trends or both, the following players may struggle to justify their price tag.

When he's in the lineup, Allen Craig (1B, STL)...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Batters

Francisco Alvarez has carried forward his big second half into the spring, giving him legit 30-HR breakout potential in 2026.
Mar 21 2026 3:16am
Kevin McGonigle's top prospect pedigree has been on full display this spring, including premium batted ball quality and a mature plate approach.
Mar 21 2026 3:15am
Lars Nootbaar's marginal surface stats in 2025 hid some elite batted ball quality, making him a premium end-gamer.
Mar 16 2026 3:10am
Pete Crow-Armstrong's marginal batted ball quality, shaky plate skills, and extreme level of chase make him a risky bet to maintain his 2025 value.
Mar 9 2026 3:05am
Ben Rice's massive gains in exit velocity and against southpaws in 2025 make him a premium breakout target.
Mar 2 2026 3:05am

Tools