SPECULATOR: Searching for the next A.J. Burnett

Building on last week's search for the next Edwin Encarnación, this week we turn our eye toward the pitchers. Our subject for this exercise will be Pirates RHP A.J. Burnett, who last year finished 16-10 with a 3.51 ERA, 105 BPV, and earned $15 in 5x5 value. The trick, of course, is that Burnett hadn't posted that level of value since 2007-08.

So, if we want to cast a net for pitchers who might replicate Burnett's unlikely resurgence, our search criteria might look something like this:

  • age 30 or older;
  • has multiple seasons of sub-4.00 xERA (or 90+ BPV) in his past;
  • did not achieve that sub-4.00 xERA (or 90+ BPV) in 2012;
  • has changed teams or other circumstances this year that might portend a "fresh start" akin to what...

Almost!

You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Speculator

Our annual exercise checking in on the MLB returns from this year's rookie class, and speculating on revised outlooks going forward.
Jul 30 2025 3:09am
QBaB scores have been integrated into the site this year, so let's take them for a spin.
Jul 23 2025 3:07am
They'll be entering uncharted workload territory come September, so it's best you develop some contingency plans ahead of time.
Jul 16 2025 3:09am
An annual exercise looking at players most likely to be traded, and more importantly, speculate on who might step in.
Jul 9 2025 3:06am
They weren't drafted early, but they've delivered. We'll name a speculative 1H All-Star Team and speculate on their second half.
Jul 2 2025 3:09am

Tools