HEAD-TO-HEAD: Identifying Consistent SP Targets for 2023


In 2020, we developed an Aggregate Consistency Score (ACS) that ranked starting pitchers on a scale of 20-100, with 100 being the best (i.e., most consistent) rating a pitcher could receive. ACS factors in PQS-DOMinant starts, PQS-DISasters, Quality-Consistency Scores and health. Now, with 2 full years of data post the shortened 2020 season, we evaluate which starting pitchers have been most consistent. Using this information we can then draw up a game plan for how to create your own lists of draft day targets.

How ACS is Derived

ACS assigns each pitcher 1-5 points for each of the following 4 factors: (1) PQS-DOMinant (DOM%) starts; (2) PQS-DISasters (DIS%); (3) Quality-Consistency Scores (QC Scores) and (4) health, which...


You’re just a few clicks away from accessing this feature and hundreds more throughout the year that have a singular goal in mind: Winning your league. Subscribe to BaseballHQ.com here!

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

More From Head-To-Head

Let's identify those pools of target hitters that will give our H2H teams the most consistent performances this year.
Feb 15 2023 1:03am
With approximately two months in the books, it's a good time to assess which hitters are performing consistently, as well as those who are not.
Jun 1 2021 12:03am
Head-to-Head leagues are largely not compatible with a 60-game season; and the Chris Sheltons of the world (pictured) will help determine team outcomes more than normal. But if you are going to play H2H this year, here are a few strategical thoughts and H2H Principles to take away.
Jul 7 2020 1:04am
Streaming pitchers is one of the most common uses of the waiver wire across platform or league format. It's time to utilize hitter streaming to get a competitive advantage over the rest of your league.
Mar 18 2020 1:04am
Is it true that only the dead are continuously consistent? We’ll aim for consistency in life by combining starting pitchers’ dominance, implosions, and health in a single metric.
Feb 27 2020 1:03am