FANALYTICS: A critical analysis of the first-round/$30 player pool, a redux

The facts are the facts: our success rate for projecting which 15 players will earn the most roto-value in any given season is about 35%. That's terrible.

Lately, I've been hearing a growing din of apathy. So what? Who cares? Nobody expects players to finish exactly where we pick them anyway. Still, Internet discussion became contentious when I chose Jose Abreu over Paul Goldschmidt as the 3rd overall pick at the FSTA Experts draft, and when Todd Zola selected Anthony Rizzo at #7. Does it matter?

Full text available to BaseballHQ full subscription subscribers only. Please Subscribe at

Click here to subscribe

  For more information about the terms used in this article, see our Glossary Primer.